Using the search means you accept our Terms of Use.

Search

Audio and Music Guides

MP3 vs AAC: Which Lossy Format Is the Better Choice?

MP3 vs AAC is a contest between two lossy formats from the same family. MP3 was standardised in 1993. AAC followed in 1997, designed as its successor. AAC usually sounds better at the same bitrate. MP3 plays on almost any device. Which matters more depends on the equipment you own.

You already use both, probably without choosing. MP3 arrives in .mp3 files. AAC hides inside .m4a files, in the sound of most online video and in many streaming services. YouTube, for instance, delivers audio as AAC or Opus, not MP3. So the practical question is often whether to keep AAC as it is or convert it.

MP3 and AAC side by side

The table compares MP3 and AAC on age, sound and file size at the same bitrate, file ending, device support and licensing, with the size row worked out for 128 kbps.

What differsMP3AAC
Standardised19931997
Sound at the same bitrateNeeds more bitrate for equal qualityCleaner at 96 to 128 kbps
File size at the same bitrateAbout 1 MB per minute at 128 kbpsThe same, about 1 MB per minute
Usual file ending.mp3.m4a
Device supportNearly every player and stereoRecent phones, computers, browsers
LicensingPatents expired, programme ended 2017Fees for makers of encoders and decoders only

Sound quality: MP3 vs AAC at the same bitrate

AAC gets more sound out of each kilobit. It analyses steady passages in blocks of 1,024 samples, against 576 for MP3, which gives finer frequency detail. For sudden sounds it switches to shorter blocks than MP3 can, which reduces the smeared echo before a drum hit. It also handles stereo more flexibly and supports surround sound, which standard MP3 does not.

The gain shows most at low bitrates. At 96 to 128 kbps, AAC generally sounds cleaner than MP3, with fewer swishing artefacts on cymbals and voices. In a public blind listening test in 2014, AAC at 96 kbps was rated above MP3 at about 128 kbps. From about 192 kbps the two are hard to separate, and at 256 kbps most listeners cannot tell them apart. File size does not separate them either: at the same bitrate both take the same space, about 1 MB a minute at 128 kbps. The MP3 bitrate guide shows what each setting gives up.

Device support: where each format plays

MP3 is the format every maker had to support. Car stereos with a USB port, DVD players, budget portable players, game consoles and smart TVs nearly all read it. Much older hardware reads nothing else. If a file has to work on equipment you have never seen, such as a relative's car or a venue's sound system, MP3 is the safe pick.

AAC is well supported on anything recent. iPhones, Android phones, Windows, macOS and all major browsers play it, usually as an .m4a file. Trouble starts with older gear. Some car stereos and basic players list only MP3 and WMA in the manual and will skip an .m4a file. An MP3 copy solves that, and why a downloaded MP3 will not play lists what strict car stereos accept.

Licensing: why MP3 became free to build and AAC did not

MP3 was once a licensed technology. Makers of encoders and players paid patent royalties until the patents ran out, and the licensing programme was closed in 2017. Since then anyone may build MP3 software or hardware without a patent fee. That history explains its reach: for two decades it was the one format every device maker agreed to include.

AAC is still covered by a patent licensing programme. The fees fall on companies that make encoders and decoders, such as phone and software makers. No fee is charged for distributing, streaming or listening to AAC audio. For you as a listener the cost is zero either way. Licensing matters only because it shaped which devices support which format.

Converting AAC to MP3, and which format to choose

Converting between lossy formats always costs quality, because the second encoder discards more from audio that was already reduced. An MP3 from a YouTube to MP3 converter has been through two such passes, because YouTube's own stream is AAC or Opus. That is acceptable for compatibility, but it is the reason a download can sound slightly duller than the stream. The page on why a downloaded MP3 sounds different explains the effect.

So keep AAC files as AAC if your devices play them. Convert to MP3 only for hardware that refuses .m4a, and use 192 kbps or more to limit the extra loss. When you are making files from a lossless source yourself, pick AAC for recent phones and computers and MP3 for mixed or older equipment. The audio format comparison adds Opus, WAV and FLAC to the picture.

Questions and answers

Is AAC better than MP3 at the same bitrate?

Generally yes. AAC was designed later with more precise tools, and at 96 to 128 kbps it usually sounds cleaner than MP3. The advantage shrinks as the bitrate rises. At 256 kbps and above, most listeners cannot hear a difference between well-encoded files in either format.

Is an M4A file the same thing as AAC?

Not exactly. M4A is the container, the file that wraps the audio, and AAC is the usual sound format inside it. Nearly all .m4a music files hold AAC. A few hold Apple's lossless format instead, which is why some M4A files are far larger than others.

Will an AAC file play on an old car stereo or MP3 player?

Often not. Older units commonly read MP3, and sometimes WMA, but ignore .m4a files. Check the manual or the label near the USB port for the supported formats. If AAC is not listed, an MP3 copy at 192 kbps or higher is the practical answer.

Should I convert my AAC files to MP3?

Only if a device you rely on cannot play them. Each conversion between lossy formats removes a little more detail, and it never adds any. If you do convert, keep the original AAC files and choose 192 kbps or more for the MP3 copies.

Why is YouTube audio AAC or Opus instead of MP3?

Both are newer and more efficient than MP3, so they deliver similar quality with less data, which matters for streaming. Most videos carry audio at roughly 128 to 160 kbps. An MP3 made from that stream cannot exceed its quality, whatever bitrate is printed on the file.

Does AAC make smaller files than MP3?

At the same bitrate the files are the same size, because size is bitrate multiplied by time. The saving comes from being able to use a lower bitrate for similar quality. An AAC file at 128 kbps is often judged close to an MP3 at a somewhat higher setting.

Is 256 kbps AAC better than 320 kbps MP3?

They are close enough that most listeners cannot tell them apart. AAC is the more efficient format, so 256 kbps AAC holds up against 320 kbps MP3 while taking 20 percent less space: 1.9 MB a minute against 2.4 MB. Choose by what your devices play, not by the number.

Which format should I choose for podcasts or voice recordings?

Both work well for speech. MP3 remains the usual choice for podcasts because support for it among podcast apps and players is close to universal, and 64 to 128 kbps is enough for a clear voice. AAC can sound a little cleaner at the lowest bitrates if all your listeners use recent devices.

Updated: