Using the search means you accept our Terms of Use.

Search

Audio and Music Guides

Audio Format Comparison: MP3, AAC, Opus, WAV and FLAC

This audio format comparison covers the five formats behind most music files and streams: MP3, AAC, Opus, WAV and FLAC. They differ in one basic way. MP3, AAC and Opus are lossy and discard some sound to stay small. FLAC is lossless: it shrinks the file and discards nothing. WAV normally stores uncompressed PCM. The chart below sets them side by side so you can pick by need.

One rule sits above the whole table. A file can never hold more detail than the recording it was made from. Converting a 128 kbps MP3 to FLAC or WAV gives a much larger file with the same sound. Pick the format when the audio is first captured or bought, because changing it later cannot add quality.

Audio format chart: compression, size per minute and device support

The table compares the five formats by compression type, size per minute, device support and typical use; sizes assume stereo music, with MP3 at 128 to 320 kbps, AAC at 128 to 256 kbps, Opus at 64 to 160 kbps, WAV at CD quality (1,411 kbps) and FLAC at 50 to 70 percent of the WAV size.

FormatCompression typeSize per minutePlays onGood fit for
MP3Lossy, detail removedAbout 1 to 2.4 MBNearly every devicePhones, cars, sharing files
AAC (M4A)Lossy, more efficient than MP3About 1 to 1.9 MBRecent phones, computers, browsersStreaming and recent devices
OpusLossy, efficient at low bitratesAbout 0.5 to 1.2 MBCurrent browsers and AndroidOnline video and voice
WAVNone, raw PCMAbout 10.6 MBAlmost any deviceRecording and editing
FLACLossless, exact copyAbout 5.3 to 7.4 MBAndroid and Windows, limited on AppleArchives and CD rips

Lossy, lossless and uncompressed: three kinds of file

WAV stores sound as raw PCM samples. For CD quality that means 44,100 samples a second on each of two channels, at 16 bits per sample. Nothing is removed and nothing is squeezed. FLAC takes the same samples and packs them more tightly, much as a ZIP file does with documents. On playback it rebuilds every bit exactly, as the MP3 vs FLAC page explains.

MP3, AAC and Opus are lossy. An encoder analyses the music and drops detail that hearing is least likely to notice, such as quiet sounds masked by louder ones. The saving is large: an MP3 at 128 to 320 kbps is 77 to 91 percent smaller than CD-quality WAV. AAC is newer than MP3 and generally keeps more quality at the same bitrate, a point covered in MP3 vs AAC.

Opus is the newest of the three lossy formats. It was published in 2012 as an open, royalty-free standard. That standard recommends 64 to 128 kbps for stereo music, and at the low end of that range an MP3 sounds rough. YouTube stores a video's sound as AAC or Opus, so a YouTube to MP3 converter has to re-encode that stream to make an MP3.

File size by format: megabytes per minute

Size follows bitrate. CD-quality WAV runs at 1,411 kbps, which is about 10.6 MB for each minute of stereo sound. FLAC usually lands at 50 to 70 percent of that, so 5.3 to 7.4 MB a minute, depending on how dense the music is. A solo piano compresses further than a loud rock mix.

Lossy files are far smaller. An MP3 takes about 1 MB a minute at 128 kbps and 2.4 MB at 320 kbps. AAC is commonly used at 128 to 256 kbps, so about 1 to 1.9 MB. Opus at 64 to 160 kbps takes about 0.5 to 1.2 MB. A four-minute song is about 42 MB as WAV, 21 to 30 MB as FLAC and 3.8 to 9.6 MB as MP3. The MP3 bitrate guide has the full figures.

Device support and tagging

MP3 plays on practically every phone, computer and car stereo that can read a music file. AAC, usually in an .m4a file, plays on current phones, computers and browsers, though some older car and portable players reject it. WAV opens almost anywhere.

FLAC plays on Android and Windows without extra software, but Apple's Music app will not import it. Apple's own lossless format, ALAC, stores the same exact copy in an .m4a file that the Music app accepts. Opus plays in current browsers and on Android 5.0 or later. Car stereos and portable players made before 2012 predate the format, so check the manual of a newer one before you copy Opus files to it.

Tags are the labels inside a file: title, artist, album, track number and cover art. MP3 carries them as ID3 tags, which nearly every player reads. M4A files and FLAC have their own tag systems and handle cover art well. WAV is the weak one. Its metadata support is patchy, so a WAV library often shows only file names.

Which audio format is best for phones, editing and archives

For a phone with limited storage, use MP3 or AAC at 128 to 192 kbps. Ten gigabytes of free space holds about 170 hours of 128 kbps audio, against about 16 hours of WAV. Choose MP3 if the files must also play in an older car or on a basic player. Choose AAC if everything you own is recent.

For recording and editing, work in WAV. Every save of a lossy file re-encodes it and loses a little more, while WAV can be cut and saved again without damage, as the MP3 vs WAV page explains. For an archive of CDs or purchased lossless downloads, keep FLAC, or ALAC if the library lives in Apple's Music app. Either keeps the original exactly, holds proper tags and converts to any other format later.

Audio and Music Guides

Questions and answers

Which audio format has the best sound quality?

WAV and FLAC are equal at the top, because both reproduce the source recording exactly. FLAC simply does it in a smaller file. Among lossy formats, AAC generally sounds better than MP3 at the same bitrate. None of them can improve on the recording they were made from.

Which audio format gives the smallest file?

Opus, because it stays usable at the lowest bitrates. At 64 kbps a minute of stereo music takes about 0.5 MB. MP3 and AAC at 128 kbps take about 1 MB per minute. FLAC needs roughly 5.3 to 7.4 MB and WAV about 10.6 MB, so neither suits a device that is short of space.

Is FLAC better than AAC?

For exact sound, yes. FLAC returns every sample of the source, while AAC discards detail to save space. A four-minute song is 21 to 30 MB as FLAC and about 7.7 MB as 256 kbps AAC. At that bitrate most listeners cannot hear the gap on everyday equipment. Keep FLAC for an archive and AAC for a phone.

Which format should I pick for a phone with little storage?

Pick MP3 or AAC at 128 to 192 kbps. A four-minute song then takes about 4 to 6 MB, compared with 21 to 30 MB as FLAC and about 42 MB as WAV. On earbuds or a phone speaker, most people will not hear what the larger files add.

What is the difference between MP3 and MP4?

MP3 is an audio format. MP4 is a container, a file that holds video and sound together, usually with the sound stored as AAC. Choose MP3 when you only want to listen and MP4 when you want the picture as well. The YouTube downloader offers both from one search field.

Is Opus better than MP3?

At the same bitrate, yes for sound. In a public blind listening test in 2014, Opus at 96 kbps was rated above MP3 at about 128 kbps. MP3 wins on reach: it plays on nearly every device, while car stereos and portable players made before 2012 predate Opus. For a file that must play anywhere, MP3 is the safer pick.

Do I lose quality every time I convert between formats?

Only when a lossy format is involved. Converting between WAV and FLAC is exact in both directions. Converting to MP3 or AAC removes detail each time, and converting one lossy format to another stacks the losses. Keep a lossless original if you expect to convert again later.

Which format do I get from MP3Juice?

MP3 for audio and MP4 for video. WAV, FLAC and Opus files are not offered. The audio comes from YouTube, where it is already compressed as AAC or Opus at roughly 128 to 160 kbps, so an MP3 at a moderate bitrate matches the source. A file labelled 320 kbps from that source is larger, not better.

Updated: