Audio and Music Guides
MP3 vs FLAC: Can You Hear the Difference, and Which to Keep
MP3 vs FLAC is lossy against lossless: FLAC rebuilds the original audio bit for bit, while MP3 discards part of it for good. In practice, a well-made MP3 at a high bitrate is very hard to tell from FLAC by ear. It is also far smaller: a four-minute song takes 9.6 MB at 320 kbps, against 21 to 30 MB as FLAC.
So the useful question is what the file is for. Keep FLAC as the master copy and MP3 for everyday listening. One trap applies: a FLAC is only as good as the source it was made from. For AAC, Opus and WAV as well, see the audio format comparison.
MP3 vs FLAC comparison table
The table compares MP3 and FLAC by compression, the size of a four-minute song, audible difference, device support, tags and what each copy is for, with MP3 at 128 to 320 kbps and FLAC made from CD-quality audio.
| What differs | MP3 | FLAC |
|---|---|---|
| Compression | Lossy, data discarded | Lossless, exact copy |
| Size of a four-minute song | 3.8 to 9.6 MB | About 21 to 30 MB |
| Audible difference from the source | Rare at 320 kbps, easier to hear at 128 kbps | None |
| Plays on | Nearly every device | Android and Windows, limited on Apple |
| Tags and cover art | ID3 tags, cover art included | Own tags, cover art included |
| Keep it for | Everyday listening, phones, cars | Master copies and archives |
How lossless and lossy compression differ
FLAC, the Free Lossless Audio Codec, has been available since 2001 and is open and free of royalties. It predicts each sample from the ones before it and stores only the small error, which takes fewer bits. Decoding reverses the sums exactly. Each file also carries a checksum of the audio, so software can confirm that nothing has been corrupted.
MP3 saves space another way. Its encoder uses a model of human hearing to decide which sounds can be dropped, then describes the rest with limited precision. The lower the bitrate, the more is dropped. This cannot be undone. Decoding an MP3 gives you the approximation, never the original. The page on what an MP3 file is has the detail.
File size: MP3 vs FLAC in megabytes
FLAC typically shrinks CD-quality audio to between 50 and 70 percent of the size of an uncompressed WAV, the format covered in MP3 vs WAV. A four-minute song that takes 42 MB as WAV becomes roughly 21 to 30 MB. Quiet acoustic music compresses well. Dense, loud mixes compress less. FLAC's compression levels, 0 to 8, trade encoding time for a slightly smaller file and never change the sound.
The same song as an MP3 is 9.6 MB at 320 kbps and 3.8 MB at 128 kbps. A thousand four-minute songs need about 21 to 30 GB in FLAC and 9.6 GB as 320 kbps MP3. Storage is cheap on a desktop drive and scarce on a phone, which is why many people keep both versions.
FLAC vs 320 kbps MP3: what you can hear
In blind listening tests, most people cannot reliably pick FLAC over a 320 kbps MP3 made with a good encoder. Differences are easier to catch at 128 kbps, on revealing headphones, and with material such as harpsichord, cymbals or crowd noise. To find your own limit, compare two files of the same track without looking at the labels. The MP3 bitrate guide compares 128 and 320 kbps in detail.
The source sets the ceiling. A FLAC made from an MP3, or from online video audio that was already compressed, holds the damaged version in a bigger file. Such files can be spotted in a spectrum view, where the sound stops sharply at about 16 kHz for a 128 kbps source. YouTube audio is a compressed source of this kind. On MP3Juice it is offered as MP3 or MP4, and FLAC is not an option.
Which to keep, and where FLAC plays
Keep FLAC as the master copy when you own a lossless source, such as a CD you ripped or a download bought in a lossless format. From that master you can make MP3 or AAC copies at any bitrate, now or in ten years, without stacking one lossy encode on another. Keep MP3 for the phone, the car and anything you share.
Support is good but uneven. Android and Windows 10 and 11 play FLAC with their built-in apps. On a Mac, QuickTime Player opens it, but the Music app will not add it to a library. On iPhone, the Files app plays FLAC and the Music app does not. Older car stereos and portable players often read MP3 only, so check the manual for FLAC before you copy files to one.
Questions and answers
Does FLAC really sound better than a 320 kbps MP3?
On paper yes, in practice rarely. FLAC is an exact copy of the source and a 320 kbps MP3 is not, but in blind tests most listeners cannot tell them apart on ordinary equipment. Trained ears with good headphones sometimes can, on certain difficult passages.
Is FLAC completely lossless?
Yes. Decoding a FLAC file returns exactly the same audio samples that went into it, bit for bit, in the way that unzipping a document returns the same text. The compression level you choose affects only file size and encoding time, never the sound.
Is a FLAC made from an MP3 really lossless?
Only in a narrow sense. It preserves the MP3's decoded sound exactly, but the detail the MP3 encoder discarded is not restored. The file is several times larger and sounds the same as the MP3. A true lossless file has to come from a lossless source.
What are the disadvantages of FLAC?
Size and support. A FLAC file is two to three times the size of a 320 kbps MP3 and five to eight times the size of a 128 kbps one. Apple's Music app does not import it, and older car stereos often read MP3 only. On everyday equipment most listeners hear no gain over a 320 kbps MP3.
Is FLAC the highest quality audio format?
No format is more faithful than FLAC, because it is lossless. WAV and ALAC are its equals: all three return exactly the samples that went in. How good that sounds depends on the recording. FLAC can also hold studio resolutions such as 24-bit, 96 kHz audio, which take more space than CD quality.
FLAC or ALAC: which lossless format works on Apple devices?
ALAC. Apple's own lossless format is the one the Music app on a Mac or iPhone accepts, as an .m4a file. FLAC plays only outside the Music app. Converting a FLAC collection to ALAC loses nothing, because both formats are lossless and return the same samples.
Can I get FLAC quality from a YouTube video?
No. YouTube audio is already lossy, usually AAC or Opus at roughly 128 to 160 kbps. Any FLAC produced from it contains that compressed sound in a larger file. For that kind of source, an MP3 at a moderate bitrate is the honest match. The page on why a downloaded MP3 sounds different explains what conversion changes.
Is MP3 outdated?
No. MP3 is old, but phones, computers, car stereos and players almost all still open it, which no newer format matches. AAC and Opus reach similar quality at lower bitrates, and FLAC keeps every detail at a larger size. The core MP3 patents expired in 2017, and their licensing programme ended.
Updated: