Using the search means you accept our Terms of Use.

Search
YouTube conversion

MP3 or MP4: Which Download to Choose on MP3Juice

MP3 keeps the sound, MP4 keeps the picture too. Compare what each file holds, how big it is and where it plays, then follow the choice from the Download panel to a checked file.

5 min read · Published · Updated

Published by MP3Juice under our editorial policy.

Headline "MP3 or MP4?" next to a music file icon and a video file icon, with headphones and a phone on a desk
Contents
  1. MP3 vs MP4: what each file holds
  2. Does MP4 sound better than MP3?
  3. Which one to download: four cases
  4. Where the choice is made: the Download panel and the converter page
  5. Where the site stops and your browser takes over
  6. Check the saved file
  7. When neither format is offered

Choose MP3 when you only want to listen and MP4 when you want the picture as well: MP3 is an audio file of about 4 to 10 MB for a four-minute song, and MP4 is a video file that often takes tens of megabytes. The two are different kinds of file, not two versions of one format.

On MP3Juice both are offered for every result, as two buttons in the Download panel. This article compares the two files, shows where the choice is made and follows it through to a saved, checked file. The short version of the choice is on the YouTube downloader page.

MP3 vs MP4: what each file holds

MP3 is an audio format, and the file holds sound and nothing else. MP4 is a container: one file that wraps a video stream and an audio stream together, with the sound usually stored as AAC. The table compares the two on five points.

PointMP3MP4
What the file holdsAudio onlyVideo with its audio
File name ends in.mp3.mp4
Size of a four-minute songRoughly 4 to 10 MBOften tens of megabytes
Where it playsAlmost any device or music appPhones, computers and video players
Choose it forListening, playlists and small storageKeeping the picture, such as a live performance

The names mislead. MP4 is not a newer MP3. MP3 is short for MPEG-1 Audio Layer III and MP4 for MPEG-4 Part 14, and the first stores sound while the second wraps picture and sound together. The audio format comparison sets MP3 beside AAC, the format most MP4 files use for sound.

Does MP4 sound better than MP3?

Hardly, and never better than the video. Both files start from the same stream, which YouTube stores at roughly 128 to 160 kbps for most videos. The sound inside an MP4 is normally that AAC stream passed on without a new encode, while an MP3 is the same stream decoded and encoded again. How each file is made is the conversion service's decision. Where the stream is passed on untouched, the MP4 is one step closer to the source, and the difference is small beside the difference in size.

A bigger number does not change this. A 320 kbps MP3 built from that stream is a larger file with the same sound. Which qualities are listed on MP3Juice depends on the source video and on the external conversion service, so the options differ from one result to the next.

Which one to download: four cases

The use decides. Four cases cover most choices:

  • You will only listen: MP3. It plays with the screen off and opens in almost any music app.
  • The picture is the point: MP4, for a music video, a live performance or a dance tutorial.
  • Storage or mobile data is short: MP3. A four-minute MP3 at 128 kbps takes about 3.8 MB, and the same song as video often takes 15 to 60 MB. The sums are in how much data a song download uses.
  • A car stereo or an older music player: MP3, the format such devices are most likely to read.

What an MP4 holds, how to estimate its size and why a device may refuse to play one are covered in MP4 files from MP3Juice.

Where the choice is made: the Download panel and the converter page

A search by song name, the route set out under MP3 download by title or artist, ends in a list of results, each with a Download button. That button opens a panel holding two buttons of its own: Download MP3 and Download MP4. Each one opens the download options supplied by an external conversion service.

A pasted YouTube link skips the results list. The converter page shows the video's title and channel, a preview player and a Choose a format area with MP3 and MP4 options. Check the title and channel before choosing a format. If they are not what you expected, the link you copied belongs to a different video. The YouTube to MP3 converter page describes that route.

After you pick an option, the service prepares the file. That can take a moment, and longer for a long video. Do not leave the page before your browser reports a download in progress.

Where the site stops and your browser takes over

MP3Juice does not store or host media files. Once you pick a download option, the file comes from the conversion service and your browser saves it. From that moment the browser is in charge.

That explains several things people attribute to the site. The folder is set by the browser, normally Downloads. Any prompt asking you to confirm or allow the download belongs to the browser or the operating system. On Android the file lands in the Download folder. On an iPhone it goes to the Downloads folder of the Files app. The whole route, from the first search to the saved file, is in how to use MP3Juice.

Check the saved file

A finished download is not yet a confirmed one. Four quick checks settle it:

  1. Start the file from your browser's list of downloads. It should begin playing in a music or video app.
  2. Confirm the ending: .mp3 for audio, .mp4 for video. Do not open anything that arrives as a program or an installer.
  3. Listen to the start, the middle and the end. A file that stops early was cut off during transfer and should be downloaded again.
  4. Rename the file if its name is unclear, and move it out of Downloads to wherever you keep music.

If the file fails one of these checks, delete it and go back to the results. A second attempt on a different upload is quicker than trying to repair a broken file.

When neither format is offered

Some videos offer no working options. Private videos, age-restricted videos, region-blocked videos, live streams and very long uploads are the usual cases. The fix is a different upload of the same song, not repeated attempts on the same one. Each case is explained in why some YouTube videos will not convert.

A result that was removed after a copyright notice no longer appears in searches at all. For failures with an error message or a stalled download, use the MP3 download troubleshooting guide.

One limit sits outside the software. Only save a recording when you made it, when its owner has given permission or a licence, or when it is public domain or under an open licence. Each country sets its own rules.