Some YouTube videos will not convert to MP3 or MP4. Private, age-restricted and region-blocked videos, live streams and very long uploads may fail, whichever format you choose. The cause lies with the video or with the external conversion service that prepares the file, so pressing Download again changes nothing.
This article takes the five cases in turn. For each it gives the rule behind the failure, the sign that shows it before you wait for a file, and what to try in its place. The normal case, in which a public video becomes an audio file, is described on the video to MP3 page.
Which YouTube videos cannot be converted, and why
MP3Juice finds a video and shows it to you. An external conversion service prepares the MP3 or MP4, and the site itself stores no media. That service has to fetch the video from YouTube first. When YouTube keeps a video closed, or the service declines it, no download options appear. The route a video takes when it does open is set out in YouTube audio and video conversion.
The table lists the five cases with the rule behind each one and the sign to look for:
| Kind of video | Why it fails | How to recognise it |
|---|---|---|
| Private | YouTube shows it only to its owner and to people the owner chose | It is missing from YouTube's search results, and a saved link no longer plays |
| Age-restricted | YouTube plays it only for signed-in viewers aged 18 or over | Play does not run it here, and YouTube asks you to sign in on its own site |
| Region-blocked | The owner or YouTube has closed it in some countries | YouTube reports that the video is not available in a country or region |
| Live stream or Premiere | The broadcast has not ended, so there is no finished recording | A live label or a countdown on the YouTube watch page |
| Very long upload | The conversion service may decline the length | A running time of an hour or more in the player |
Private and deleted videos
YouTube shows a private video only to its owner and to the people the owner has chosen. A private video does not appear in YouTube's search results, so a search here does not list it either. You meet the case with a link you saved earlier: the address still exists, but the video behind it has since been made private or deleted.
Nothing on your side opens a private video. If the upload is your own, YouTube Studio lets you download it as an MP4 file, and how to download MP3 from YouTube lists that and the other official options. An unlisted video is a different case: anyone who has its link can watch it, so the link still opens a converter page.
Age-restricted videos
YouTube plays an age-restricted video only for signed-in viewers aged 18 or over, and not in the embedded players of most other websites. Both rules matter here. Play on MP3Juice opens an embedded YouTube player. For an age-restricted video, YouTube sends you from that player to its own site to sign in. The conversion request is not a signed-in viewer either, so it usually fails.
A restriction often belongs to one upload and not to the song. A music video can be restricted for its pictures while the audio-only upload of the same song is open. Search for the title again and pick the official audio or a lyric video.
Region-blocked videos
A video can be open in one country and closed in the next. YouTube gives two reasons. The owner has made the video available only in certain countries, usually because of licensing, or YouTube has blocked it to comply with local law. A request that comes from a closed region gets nothing to convert.
The block belongs to the upload. The same song usually exists in more than one upload, and a second one may be open where the first is not. Go back to the results and try another.
Live streams and Premieres
A live stream is not a finished video. Until the broadcast ends and the channel publishes the recording, there is nothing to convert. A Premiere works in a similar way. YouTube creates the watch page before the video is shown, and until the countdown ends that page may hold only a trailer. After the Premiere the video stays on the channel as a normal upload.
Waiting is the only fix. Search again once the recording or the premiered video is public. The YouTube downloader page lists the same limits for MP4 files.
Very long uploads
Length is the one limit that the conversion service sets, and no fixed figure can be promised. Mixes, full albums, whole services and compilations of an hour or more may be refused, or may take a long time to prepare. The service has to fetch and encode the whole soundtrack, as the five stages of a video to MP3 conversion show. The file is large as well: an hour of MP3 at 128 kbps comes to about 58 MB, and two hours to about 115 MB.
To get one song out of a long upload, open the video on YouTube and read the track list in its description. Then search for that title and its artist here.
What to try when a video will not convert
Repeating the same request changes none of the five cases. Work through these four steps instead:
- Press Play on the result. If the preview does not run, the video is closed to this site as well, and another upload is the quicker route.
- Go back to the results and choose another upload of the same song, such as the official audio or a lyric video.
- For a mix, an album or another long recording, search for the single track by title and artist.
- For a live stream or a Premiere, wait until the recording is public, then search again.
If ordinary singles fail as well, the cause is not the video. It is more likely your connection or the service, and the checks for MP3Juice not working are the place to look.
A pasted address that opens a list of results was not read as a video link. Playlist and channel links are treated as an ordinary search. The YouTube to MP3 converter page names the link forms that open a converter page.
A missing result is not a failed conversion
Results removed after a copyright notice are no longer shown. A removed video is left out of the list, and rewording the query does not bring it back. A search that was removed after a notice, or that contains a phrase this site blocks, shows the notice No results for this search instead of a list. Neither case is a conversion fault, so none of the steps above apply.
How to check that a conversion really finished
A finished download can still be a bad one. Run these five checks before you go offline or delete anything:
- Open the browser's download list and confirm the transfer completed.
- Read the full file name. It should end in .mp3 or .mp4.
- Compare the size with the length. A four-minute song is about 3.8 MB at 128 kbps and 9.6 MB at 320 kbps, so a file of a few kilobytes is an error page.
- Play the start, the middle and the last ten seconds. An ending that cuts off means the transfer was interrupted.
- Check that the running time matches the video you chose.
If a check fails, delete the file and start again from the results page. Renaming a saved web page to .mp3 does not turn it into audio. When the conversion worked and the transfer failed, the browser shows a message under the file name, and what each error message means decodes it.
Rights to the audio
Convert only material you made yourself, have a licence or permission for, or that is in the public domain or under an open licence. A video being public on YouTube does not settle that question, and the rules differ by country. The page on whether MP3Juice is legal shows how to apply the rule to a video.
